Arrhythmogenic right
ventricular dysplasia (ARVD), also known as arrhythmogenic
right ventricular cardiomyopathy (ARVC), is a genetic cause
for sudden cardiac arrest (SCA).In
ARVD, there is progressive replacement of normal tissue of the
heart, the myocyte, with fat and fibrous tissue (scar tissue).
This tends to occur predominantly in the right ventricle (RV)
of the heart.The
replacement of the normal heart tissue predisposes the
individual to arrhythmias (abnormal heart rhythm secondary to
abnormal electrical activity of the heart), hence the name,
arrhythmogenic [prone to arrhythmia] right ventricular
dysplasia [abnormally formed] = ARVD.This disease tends to affect any where from 1 in
1000 to 1 in 5000 individuals. The reason for this discrepancy
is that the diagnosis of ARVD is difficult to make, and it can
be mistaken for other disease states. ARVD has a higher
prevalence in certain communities, the best well known in
northeast Italy.Clinically, ARVD is relevant because it is an
important cause of suddendeath in individuals
<30 years of age and has been foundin up to 20%
of sudden deaths in young people.
Genetics
30 % cases of ARVD occur
in families. This may be an underestimation as the genes
responsible for this disease may or may not express themselves
in affected patients, termed low penetrance. If these genes do
express themselves, it may be with varying degrees, a
condition known as variable expression.
.Low penetrance and variable
expression make it difficult to trace the disease along a
family line.
The genes responsible for ARVD may follow two
forms of inheritance, autosomal dominant and autosomal
recessive. The autosomal dominant (AD) form is the most
common. In this form, anyone possessing the gene is at risk
for having this syndrome. Furthermore, offspring of people
with the mutant gene have a 50% chance of inheriting it from
their affected parent. The autosomal recessive (AR) pattern of
inheritance is far less common. An individual must receive
mutant genes form both their parents, otherwise they will be
silent carriers of the mutant genes with no physical
manifestation. The AR form is mainly associated with a certain
syndrome called Naxos (named for the Greek island where it was
first noted) disease, in which there is ARVD along with
disorders of the skin and hair. Other conditions similar to
Naxos disease have also been linked to an AR inheritance of
mutant genes.
Genetic
counseling for families of patients who have a relative with
ARVD is available at our Genetic Cardiac Program. Genotyping
has two roles: first, it will allow confirmation of ARVD in
index cases [first member of the family to present with
disease] and, second, it will allow for efficient screening of
extended family members. In patients affected with ARVD,
comprehensive screening for gene mutations will yield a
positive result in approximately 40 to 50% of cases. Armed
with this knowledge, clinicians can employ focused specific
genetic analysis to screen family members. Due to slowly
progressive nature of this disease, asymptomatic family
members found to have genes linked to ARVD should be monitored
aggressively for development of this disease.
Pathophysiology
Regardless of the mode
of inheritance, it appears that the mutant genes code for
proteins that make up desmosomes, which are intracellular
adhesion complexes that provide mechanical connections between
cardiac myocytes (heart cells). When placed under mechanical
stress, the impaired desmosomes cause myocytes to detach from
each other leading to cell death. This cell death causes
inflammation with scar formation and fat deposition. Fatty
replacementinvolves the whole thickness of the RV
in 45%, the outer half of RV free wall in 27%, the outer
two-thirdsin 28% of cases. These fibrofatty
islands act as areas of reentry giving rise to ventricular
tachycardia, VT. Reentry may be thought of as short circuit in
the heart in which electrical currents can cycle rapidly and
then chaotically. Initially the disease process is localized,
occurring in three discrete areas of the right ventricle known
as the “triangle of dysplasia”. This triangle describes the
areas involved: the posterior wall, the apex, and the outflow
tract of the RV. Gradually the disease spreads from these
discrete areas to involve the rest of the RV. The left
ventricle (LV) and the intraventricular septum are usually
spared.If
LV involvement occurs, it tends to occur as a late
manifestation.
Clinical Presentation
When symptoms are
present, they tend to occur around 30 yrs of age. However,
patients’ age can range from 10 to 50 years.Men and women appear to be equally affected. The
most common symptoms of ARVD are due to an arrhythmia, or due
to decreased blood supply to vital organs, such as the brain,
caused by an arrhythmia. Symptoms include palpitations
(awareness of ones heart beat), dizziness, shortness of
breath, syncope (loss of conciseness), or near syncope.
Unfortunately, SCA may also be the presenting symptom;
patients with no prior symptoms may present with SCA. Some
patients may be asymptomatic, and the diagnosis of ARVD is
suspected due to a positive family history or findings on
noninvasive tests such as an echocardiogram or ECG.
As previously mentioned, the replacement of
normal heart muscles with fat and fibrous tissue predispose to
the development of arrhythmias. The most common type of
arrhythmias initiate from the RV. These may range from
premature ventricle contractions to sustained VT. The
frequency of such arrhythmias in ARVD varies with the severity
of the disease. Patients with severe forms of the disease tend
to have arrhythmias more commonly.
There seems to be an
increased association of VT and SCA with exercise in patients
with ARVD. It is presumed that genetically predisposed
athletes have increased mechanical stress placed on the heart
promoting a more severe and advanced form of the
disease.Also exercise leads to increased catecholamine
levels that may predispose to development of VT.Anyone identified with ARVD should avoid
competitive athletics or extremes of physical exertion because
these activities would predispose to SCA.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of ARVD presents a difficult
challenge. Even normal hearts have some degree of fat and
fibrous tissue. Generally, there is an effort to document
abnormal areas of right ventricular dilatation and function
with echocardiography and MRI (Fig 1,2). However,
echocardiography and MRI may be inaccurate at detecting
abnormal motion of the RV, and changes that occur on an ECG in
patients with ARVD can occur in different disease states.
Thus, requiring just one specific finding might lead to a
missed diagnosis in patients who truly have ARVD, or might
label patients with healthy hearts as having ARVD.
Figure
1 Video of MRI Showing Dilatation and
Poor
Right Ventricular Wall Motion
MRI images couresy
of Dr. Steve Wolfe, Advanced Cardiac Imaging, New York
City
Note severe hypokinesis of RV with preserved
LV wall motion
Diffuse fibrosis of the RV wall with preservation
of normal LV tissue (fibrous tissue appears white normal
cardiac tissue appears black; see arrows)
MRI images courtesy
of Dr. Steve Wolfe, Advanced Cardiac Imaging, New York
City
ARVD should be
considered in patients who present with VT arising from the RV
(Figure 3) in the absence of overt heart disease, or in cases
of SCA, occurring particularly during exercise. In order to
improve the accuracy of diagnosis, a list of diagnostic
criteria has been formulated (Table 1). These criteria
consist of findings typically seen in ARVD and cover several
different diagnostic modalities.They include the patient’s family history,
patients own history of arrhythmias, ECG findings (Figure 4),
findings on imaging studies and on biopsy. Among these broad
categories the criteria are divided into major and minor. A
diagnosis of ARVD can be made when two major criteria, or one
major plus two minor criteria, or four minor criteria alone
are met. This combination of criteria helps detect patients
who truly have the disease. Unfortunately, even with these
criteria, patients with less severe forms of the disease can
be missed.
Figure
3. Electrocardiogram of VT
Arising from RV
Table
1 Criteria for Diagnosis of ARVD
Diagnosis depends on 2 major and 2 minor criteria
or 4 minor criteria
Criteria
Major
Minor
Family
History
Familial disease confirmed at
necropsy or surgery
Family history of premature sudden
death (<35 years) caused be suspected ARVD
Family history of ARVD
ECG
depolarization/conduction
abnormalities
Epsilon waves or prolongation of the
QRS complex ( ≥ 110 msec) in the right precordial
leads( V1 – V3)
Late potentials seen on signal
averaged ECG
Repolarization
abnormalities
Inverted T waves in the right
precordial leads in patients > 12 in the absence of
right bundle branch block
Tissue
characterization of walls
Fibrofatty replacement of myocardium
on endomyocardial biopsy.
Global or regional
dysfunction and structural
alterations
Severe dilation and reduction of RV
ejection fraction with minimal LV involvement
Mild global RV dilation or ejection
fraction reduction with normal LV
Localized RV aneurysms
Mild segmental dilation of the
RV
Severe segmental dilation of the
RV
Regional RV hypokinesia
Arrhythmia
Left bundle branch block type
ventricular tachycardia (sustained and
nonsustained)(ECG,
Holter, exercise testing)
Frequent ventricular extrasystoles
(more than 1,000/24 h)
(Holter).
Figure
4
Epsilon Wave
The epsilon wave is
found in about 50% of those with ARVD. This is described as a
terminal notch in the QRS complex. It is due to slowed
intraventricular conduction.
Treatment
Currently, no definitive
treatment is present which cures the disease. The goal of
therapy is to prevent death from VT and SCA. This is
effectively accomplished by using implantedcardioverter-defibrillator (ICD). ICD
implantation is generally recommended for patients who have
had a documented episode of sustained VT, SCA or in patients
who are thought to be at high risk for SCA (Table 2). Use of
antiarrhythmic drugs (AADs), i.e. sotalol, is reserved for
patients who are not candidates for ICD or after ICD
implantation to prevent frequent ICD discharges. Milder forms
of the disease with no symptoms suggestive of arrhythmia may
be treated with beta blocking agents, e.g.
metoprolol.Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) targeted to the
site of the arrhythmia may be occasionally be recommend for
high risk patients who are not candidates for an ICD, or those
who have arrhythmias refractory to treatment post ICD. In this
context indications for RFA are similar to those of
AAD.As mentioned previously, increased
physical activity may advance disease and lead to arrhythmias.
Thus, patients with ARVD should not participate in competitive
sports or in activities in which loss of conciseness may lead
to harm e.g. scuba diving. Low intensity activities such as
golf are considered safe.
Table
2 High Risk Features in Patients with
ARVD
Younger patients
Patients who present with recurrent
syncope
Patients with history of cardiac
arrest or sustained VT
Patients with clinical signs of RV
failure
Patients with LV involvement
Patients with or having a family
member with the high risk ARVD gene (ARVD2)
Patients with an increase in QRS
dispersion ≥ 40 msec(maximum measured QRS duration minus minimum
measured QRS duration)
Patients with Naxos disease
Prognosis
The overall prognosis in
ARVD is not clear. Small retrospective analysis of patients
with ARVD has quantified an annual mortality of
2.3%.As may be expected, patients with mild disease
and nonsustained episodes of VT tend to have a relatively
better prognosis than patients with severe disease, a history
of sustained VT, or evidence of right or left sided heart
failure. Family members of affected patients also need to be
screened periodically using a modified diagnostic criteria,
which takes into account minor abnormalities of the ECG,
Holter, or echocardiographic criteria.(Table 3), as with time
they may develop ARVD.
Table
3 Proposed Modification of Task Force Criteria for the
Diagnosis of Familial ARVC
ARVC in
First-Degree Relative Plus One of the Following:
1.
ECG
T-wave
inversion in right precordial leads (V2 and
V3)
2.
SAECG
Late
potentials seen on signal-averaged ECG
3.
Arrhythmia
LBBB
type VT on ECG, Holter monitoring or during exercise
testing
Mild
global RV dilatation and/or EF reduction with normal
LV
Mild
segmental dilatation of the RV
Regional RV
hypokinesia
ARVC = arrythmogenic right ventricular
cardiomyopathy; ECG = electrocardiogram; EF = ejection
fraction; LBBB = left bundle branch block; RV = right
ventricle; SAECG = signal-averaged electrocardiography; VT =
ventricular tachycardia. * Previously >1,000/24-h
period in task force criteria.
Modified fromHamid M.S., Norman
M., Quraishi A., Firoozi S. et al. Prospective evaluation of
relatives for familial arrhythmogenic right ventricular
cardiomyopathy/dysplasia reveals a need to broaden diagnostic
criteria, J Am Coll Cardiol16 (2002) (40), pp.
1445–1450.